Emergency CT or MRI was uncommon after urgent care X-rays for low back pain
Citation: Hood M, Samuel JKR, Khanna P, Ebada A, Rao A, Succi MD. Urgent Care Radiography for Low Back Pain Is Rarely Followed by Emergency Advanced Imaging. Journal of the American College of Radiology. Published online October 28, 2026. S1546-1440(26)00543-0. doi:10.1016/j.jacr.2026.10.023
Online first: October 28, 2026.
A new study from the IO Lab finds that emergency department CT or MRI was uncommon after urgent care X-rays for low back pain without documented warning signs. Published in the Journal of the American College of Radiology, the study examines how patients moved between these settings and the imaging resources used in each.
IO Lab researchers reviewed records from 23 urgent care centers and affiliated emergency departments between 2019 and 2025. The analysis included 16,754 imaging studies from 15,759 adults: 2,924 urgent care radiographs and 13,830 emergency department studies. Researchers screened imaging order descriptions for keywords indicating warning signs and excluded those presentations. They linked medical record numbers to identify subsequent emergency imaging.
Within 30 days, 24 urgent care radiographs were followed by an emergency department CT or MRI. That represented 0.82% of the urgent care studies, with a 95% confidence interval of 0.55% to 1.22%. Twelve of those returns occurred within the first 24 hours. Two radiologists reviewed each return, and they judged one case to involve a fracture missed on the original radiograph.
The researchers also compared resource use per imaging study through relative value units, a measure used in physician payment. Median totals were 1.43 units for urgent care radiographs and 5.14 for emergency department imaging. Converted to approximate Medicare-allowed amounts, those figures were about $48 and $171 per study. These estimates describe individual imaging services; they do not measure the total cost of a patient’s episode of care.
The findings could inform decisions about where selected patients receive imaging. The authors suggest that urgent care may offer an appropriate initial imaging setting for low-acuity back pain. However, the groups differed substantially: urgent care patients had a median age of 50, compared with 67 in the emergency department. The retrospective comparison cannot establish that the care setting itself caused the differences in imaging use.
The main outcome also has a specific scope. A low rate of later CT or MRI does not establish that every diagnosis was correct or that symptoms resolved. Identifying warning signs through order descriptions depends on what clinicians documented, and linking records within affiliated facilities may not capture care elsewhere. These considerations matter when applying the findings beyond the health system studied.
For clinicians and health systems, the study provides a starting point for evaluating imaging pathways for low-acuity back pain. Prospective research that follows symptoms, missed diagnoses and total care costs could help establish which patients benefit from each pathway. The results alone do not establish a need for routine X-rays in uncomplicated back pain.
